Editorial Article
A Car Tyre Qualifies as a Winter Tyre at 1.07. A Truck Needs 1.25. The Number Everyone Quotes Is the Truck's.
There is a number that circulates in every tyre specification meeting, and it is the wrong one. Ask what a tyre has to achieve to carry the three-peak mountain snowflake — the mark that makes an all-season tyre legally usable in a German winter or a French mountain zone — and the answer comes back as 1.25. That figure is real. It is also the heavy truck threshold.
For a passenger car it is 1.07.
This is not a technicality. It is the reason a product category worth USD 38.1 billion in 2025 has no legal definition, a binary pass mark, and a thirty-six per cent spread in performance among the tyres that hold it.
What the regulation actually says
UN Regulation No. 117, in its 04 series as amended by Supplement 2 in force from 10 January 2025, does not define an all-season tyre. The term does not appear in its definitions, and it does not appear in the US Tire Manufacturers Association’s definition of a tyre for use in severe snow conditions either. Two regulators, two continents, and neither has any legal object called all-season.
What Regulation No. 117 defines, at paragraph 2.13, is a snow tyre: a tyre whose tread pattern, tread compound or construction is primarily designed to achieve in mud and/or snow conditions a performance better than that of a normal tyre with regard to its ability to initiate and control vehicle motion. Note the grammar. That is a definition by intent. Nothing is measured.
The measurement arrives one paragraph later. Paragraph 2.13.1 defines a tyre for use in severe snow conditions as a snow tyre or special use tyre specifically designed for severe snow that fulfils the requirements of paragraphs 6.5 and 6.5.1. Paragraph 6.5.1 is the table, and the table has three columns of numbers because there are three permitted test methods and three tyre classes.
| Class | Method | Minimum snow grip index |
|---|---|---|
| C1 — passenger car | Brake on snow, SRTT14 or SRTT16 | 1.07 |
| C1 — passenger car | Acceleration, SRTT14 or SRTT16 | 1.10 |
| C2 — light truck | Spin traction, SRTT16C | 1.02 |
| C2 — light truck | Acceleration | 1.10 |
| C3 — heavy truck | Acceleration, SRTT19.5 or SRTT22.5 | 1.25 |
So a passenger car tyre qualifies at 1.07 on the brake test. A truck tyre, weighing many times as much and tested against a much larger reference tyre on the acceleration method, qualifies at 1.25. The 1.25 everyone quotes is the truck number, imported into a conversation about cars by repetition.
Then paragraph 4.2.6 closes the loop, and it is the sentence that gives the European all-season tyre its legal identity: the Alpine symbol is applied if the snow tyre or the special use tyre is classified as a tyre for use in severe snow conditions. A tyre may not carry the symbol otherwise. Which means the tyre a French driver buys as an all-season tyre, and leaves on the car through July, is type-approved as a snow tyre. It carries a snow tyre’s markings. When the abrasion limits arrive, it will carry a snow tyre’s abrasion index.
The American number is different, on a different test
North America does not harmonise with any of this. The USTMA’s Tire Information Service Bulletin 37 recognises a tyre for use in severe snow conditions at a snow grip index of at least 1.10 against SRTT14, or 1.12 against SRTT16, using ASTM F1805 on a medium packed snow surface. NHTSA adopted that criterion in FMVSS No. 139 and Transport Canada in CMVSS No. 139, and some documents express it as a traction index of 112.
The practical consequence is that the same physical tyre can be severe-snow in one jurisdiction and not in another. A tyre engineered to the European brake method at 1.08 qualifies in Europe and would not meet the American 1.12 criterion against SRTT16. Neither regulator asserts equivalence, because neither number was derived from the other.
For a manufacturer this is a fork with a cost at both ends. Build one range to the stricter number and you pay for capability the looser market does not require. Build two and you carry two validation programmes through every size in the catalogue. The difference is invisible on the sidewall.
Germany removed the cheap claim; France made the tested one sufficient
What turned a technical threshold into a market was two national decisions, taken in opposite directions and arriving at the same place.
Michelin created the product in May 2015 with the CrossClimate, the first summer-construction tyre to carry the Alpine symbol. Between then and 2025 the European all-season market grew from roughly 8 million tyres to around 50 million, on the company’s own figures and the European industry association’s. That growth needed a regulatory event, and Germany supplied the first one.
Section 52 of the German Road Traffic Regulations carried a transitional provision: tyres marked only M+S and manufactured no later than 31 December 2017 counted as winter tyres only until 30 September 2024. From 1 October 2024, the Alpine symbol is required. M+S tyres did not become illegal — they remain on sale and legal to drive — but they stopped discharging the winter requirement, which means a driver who owned a set had to buy again.
The volume response is a textbook forward-pull and payback. German car winter units rose 6.4 per cent in 2024 as the deadline approached, and the total replacement market grew 6.8 per cent to just under 47.5 million tyres. All-season rose 17.0 per cent. Then came 2025: winter units fell 7.8 per cent, summer fell 4.0 per cent, and all-season rose 6.1 per cent in a market that shrank 1.9 per cent to 46.6 million tyres. All-season reached an estimated 38.9 per cent of replacement car tyre sales against winter’s 35.7 — the first year it outsold winter, in the country that wrote the winter tyre rule.
France did the opposite and got the same result. Since 2021, the mountain-zone obligation has required, from 1 November to 31 March across 34 departments in six massifs, either removable anti-skid devices for at least two driven wheels or four winter tyres. Only 3PMSF-marked tyres are accepted as the latter. Germany withdrew the cheap claim; France made the tested one the cheapest legal answer to an obligation. All-season volume reached 5.409 million units in 2024, up 19.2 per cent, against summer down 4.7 and winter down 5.5. In the first half of 2025 it was the only season category to grow, at 6.8 per cent, reaching 39 per cent of sales.
A mark that everyone holds tells a buyer nothing
Here is where the low threshold matters commercially. In 2025 the German motoring organisation ADAC tested sixteen all-season tyres in 205/55 R16. All sixteen are legal to sell in Europe. All sixteen carry the Alpine symbol and are legal to fit in a German winter. Between the best and the worst, wet braking from 62 mph varied by 36.1 per cent: 103 feet for the best, 140 feet for the worst, with the worst still travelling at 41 mph where the best had stopped.
Every one of those tyres satisfies the mark. The mark carries no information about the difference between them.
The results also show that technical leadership in this category does not belong to the company that created it. Continental took first place on wet braking in both surface conditions and recorded the longest mileage in the test at 68,000 kilometres. Michelin’s CrossClimate 2, direct descendant of the product that started the category, finished sixth on wet braking at 110 feet. Bridgestone and Pirelli placed second and third; Goodyear fourth.
That is not a criticism of any of them. It is evidence about what the market rewards. When the qualifying mark is a floor that all credible products now clear, the differences above the floor are what a buyer needs and what the label does not show. A purchaser comparing two tyres on a shelf sees the same three-peak pictogram on both and has to reach for a wet grip letter to separate them.
The consequence is a category that competes on price and availability rather than on performance, which is visible in the tier data. In France in the first half of 2025, premium brands fell 5.4 per cent to 48.4 per cent share — below half the market for the first time since the pandemic quarter of 2020 — second-tier brands fell 16.5 per cent, and budget and entry-level brands grew 10.2 per cent to a record 22.2 per cent. The segment grew 6.8 per cent in the same half. Its growth is arriving through the tier that competes on price, because a product validated by a single pass mark is a product where a cheaper tyre can be legally equivalent.
The next regulation measures the premise
There is a date on the calendar that the category has not priced. Regulation (EU) 2024/1257 applies its abrasion requirements to new types of C1 tyres from 1 July 2028, to all C1 tyres placed on the market from 1 July 2030, allowing non-compliant stock only until 30 June 2032. The limit itself is left to a delegated act, triggered by UN WP.29’s progress by 1 July 2026 or a Commission fallback on 1 July 2027.
Under the parallel UN abrasion regime the limit is an index whose base of 1.00 applies to a normal tyre and a snow tyre alike. The additions granted go to reinforced and extra-load constructions and to low-aspect high-speed constructions. An all-season tyre is, in law, a snow tyre. It gets no allowance for being soft — and softness is the design decision that makes it work in snow.
So from 2028 the category that took 38.9 per cent of Germany by being legally sufficient in winter will be measured on the property its winter capability degrades. Complying without giving up snow grip means either a compound that resists wear without hardening, which is the hardest problem in the discipline, or a shallower, more densely siped tread that trades wear life for grip differently. Either route raises the cost of a tyre whose realised price is already below the summer tyre it displaces.
That is the shape of the next three years in this market. The regulation created the category by defining the mark, it removed the cheap alternative in the largest European market, and it now proposes to regulate the compromise that the mark requires. The number to watch is not 1.25. It was never 1.25.
The companion piece to this article, on why the all-season tyre now sells for less than the summer tyre it replaces while costing more to build, is here.
Sources
UN Regulation No. 117, 04 series, Supplement 2 in force 10 January 2025, paragraphs 2.13, 2.13.1, 4.2.6 and 6.5.1. USTMA Tire Information Service Bulletin 37; US FMVSS No. 139; Canadian CMVSS No. 139; ASTM F1805. German Road Traffic Regulations section 52, transitional provision expiring 30 September 2024. French Service-Public on the mountain-zone equipment obligation, 1 November to 31 March, 34 departments. ADAC all-season tyre test 2025, 16 tyres, 205/55 R16. Regulation (EU) 2024/1257 on tyre abrasion. Syndicat du Pneu market releases, 2024 and first half 2025. BRV German replacement market releases, March 2025 and March 2026. Tyres Europe quarterly replacement tyre market review, Q4 2025. Michelin ten-year CrossClimate review. Pheonix Research, Global All-Season Car Tyres Market, 2026–2033. Related Pheonix reports: Summer & Winter Tyres, Ultra-High Performance Tyres, and Passenger Vehicle Tyres.
