Editorial Article
In France the All-Season Tyre Now Costs Less Than the Summer Tyre It Replaces. That Is Why It Is Winning.
For the first time in the recorded series, the average all-season tyre in France costs less than the average summer tyre. In the first half of 2025 it sold for EUR 102. The summer tyre sold for EUR 105.
This is the single most informative number in a USD 38.1 billion market, because it inverts everything the category was sold as. The all-season tyre was introduced as a convenience product at a premium — two sets collapsed into one, and the buyer paid for the privilege. Ten years later it is winning the market by being the cheaper option, and it is doing that while costing more to manufacture.
The inversion, in sequence
In 2024 the two categories were at exact parity: EUR 103 for an all-season tyre, EUR 103 for a summer tyre, on the channels the French trade association studies. Across the whole car and 4×4 tyre market the average price was EUR 111.60.
By the first half of 2025 the all-season average had slipped to EUR 102 while summer held at EUR 105, in a market where the average across all car and 4×4 tyres actually rose 0.9 per cent. So the inversion was not the summer tyre deflating. It was the all-season tyre pricing itself below a rising market.
What happened in the same six months tells you where the volume came from. Total car, 4×4 and van sell-in fell 4.8 per cent and sell-out fell 4.7 per cent. Premium brands fell 5.4 per cent and dropped to 48.4 per cent share — below half the market for the first time since the pandemic quarter of 2020. Second-tier brands fell 16.5 per cent. Budget and entry-level brands, overwhelmingly imported, grew 10.2 per cent to a record 22.2 per cent. And all-season, the only season category to grow, rose 6.8 per cent to 39 per cent of sales.
Those four facts are one fact. The category’s growth is arriving through the tier that competes on price, in a market where the compliance mark that qualifies a tyre is available to every competitor at every price point.
Why it can be cheaper and still be the better decision
The all-season tyre is not competing with a summer tyre. It is competing with a summer set plus a winter set plus two changeovers a year plus storage.
Frame the purchase that way and the arithmetic changes completely. A driver who converts from two sets to one buys four tyres where they would have bought eight, and pays no changeover labour twice a year and gives up no storage. The all-season tyre can be cheaper per tyre, and still be the cheaper decision by a wide margin, because the thing it deletes is the second set.
That is the mechanism, and it has a consequence that very few forecasts in this sector account for: the segment’s growth deletes units from the market it sells into. Every converted driver removes four tyres per vehicle cycle from the replacement pool. The segment can therefore gain share while the pool contracts, and it does.
Europe in 2025: consumer replacement volume 224.133 million units, down 2 per cent, with summer down 7 per cent, winter down 2 per cent and all-season up 5 per cent. Germany: a total replacement market down 1.9 per cent to 46.6 million tyres, in which all-season was the only product group in the consumer segment that grew, at 6.1 per cent, reaching an estimated 38.9 per cent against winter’s 35.7 per cent. That is the first year all-season outsold winter in the country that wrote the winter tyre rule.
Which means an all-season growth rate is not a demand forecast. It is a share number applied to a shrinking base. Capacity planned against it will overshoot the pool.
The cost paradox
Here is the part that makes this a margin story rather than a volume story. The all-season tyre is the more expensive of the two products to build.
Winter grip needs softness: a compound that stays flexible below seven degrees Celsius, and a tread dense with sipes that open and bite. Summer durability needs stiffness: a compound that resists deformation and heat at motorway speed and load. Those requirements pull the same variables in opposite directions, and the industry’s answer since 2015 has been silica-heavy compounds with functionalised polymers and three-dimensional sipe geometry that locks under load.
Every element of that answer costs money at a specific point in the chain. Deeper tread costs compound volume. Higher silica loading costs silane coupling agent and mixing energy, and silica disperses less predictably than carbon black, which raises scrap. Three-dimensional sipes cost mould complexity, because the blades that cut them are the most precise and most wear-prone part of the tooling. And an all-season range has to hold both duty cycles across every size in the catalogue, which multiplies the validation matrix — snow index, wet grip class, rolling resistance class and noise value, measured and declared for every size.
So the more expensive tyre to make is selling for less than the cheaper one. That is not a pricing error by the industry. It is what the product’s competitive frame produces, and it is sustainable only as long as the cost gap stays inside the changeover saving the consumer receives.
The brands that are actually winning it
In 2025 the German motoring organisation ADAC tested sixteen all-season tyres in 205/55 R16 and found a 36.1 per cent spread in wet braking from 62 mph — 103 feet for the best to 140 feet for the worst, with the worst still travelling at 41 mph when the best had stopped. All sixteen are legal to sell and legal to fit in a German winter, because all sixteen carry the Alpine symbol.
That is why a pass mark cannot protect a price. Continental won the wet test and recorded the longest mileage at 68,000 kilometres; Bridgestone and Pirelli placed second and third; Michelin‘s CrossClimate 2 — the direct descendant of the product that created the category in May 2015 — finished sixth on wet braking. Hankook, Nexen and Goodyear filled the field around them. There is no durable technical franchise at the top of a category whose qualifying mark everyone clears.
That is the same fact as the tier data, seen from the product side. A category validated by a binary mark is a category where a cheaper tyre can be legally equivalent, and the buyer at the counter has no reason to pay for a difference they cannot see.
What the market is worth, and how it decomposes
The Pheonix model puts the global all-season car tyre market at USD 38,100.0 million in 2025 and USD 61,900.0 million in 2033, a compound 6.25 per cent. Units rise from 448.0 million to 570.0 million at 3.06 per cent, and realised price from USD 85.04 to USD 108.60 at 3.10 per cent.
| Component of the USD 23,800.0 million added | USD million | Share |
|---|---|---|
| More tyres | 10,375.4 | 43.59% |
| Dearer tyre and richer mix | 10,551.3 | 44.33% |
| Interaction | 2,873.3 | 12.07% |
That balance is nearly unique in this industry. In the passenger vehicle tyre market containing this segment, 68.07 per cent of growth is price. In summer and winter tyres it is 87.77 per cent. Only in the segments that are taking unit share — all-season at 44.33 and ultra-high performance at 41.6 — do price and volume contribute almost equally.
Price share and unit share move in opposite directions across this cluster. That is what a substitution mechanism looks like from inside. The segments that are gaining units cannot charge much more for them, and the segments that are losing units are the ones whose growth is entirely price.
The problem arriving in 2028
The cost side is about to get worse on a fixed timetable. Regulation (EU) 2024/1257 applies abrasion requirements to new types of C1 tyres from 1 July 2028 and to all C1 tyres from 1 July 2030, with non-compliant stock allowed only until 30 June 2032. Under the parallel UN regime the limit is an index whose base of 1.00 applies to a normal tyre and a snow tyre alike, with the additions granted only to reinforced and low-aspect high-speed constructions.
An all-season tyre is a snow tyre in law. It receives no allowance for being soft — and softness is the design decision that makes it work. Complying without giving up snow grip means either a compound that resists wear without hardening, which is the hardest problem in the discipline, or a shallower tread that trades wear life for grip differently. Either route adds cost to a tyre already selling below the summer tyre it replaces.
There is no price premium available to fund that, because the mark that qualifies the product is available to every competitor at every price point. Natural rubber due diligence arrives in the same window on the full volume, from 30 December 2026. Two compliance programmes, one bill of materials, no pricing power.
The verdict
The all-season tyre is a genuinely good product with a genuine consumer benefit, and it is winning. It is winning at parity, then at a discount, in a market where it costs more to build, and against a compliance bill it cannot pass on. Volume can grow 6.25 per cent a year inside that structure. Margin cannot.
The companion piece to this article, on the regulatory threshold that made the category possible, is here.
Sources
Syndicat du Pneu, French tyre market releases for 2024 and the first half of 2025, average selling prices and brand-tier shares. Tyres Europe quarterly replacement tyre market review, Q4 2025, full-year consumer replacement volumes by season type. BRV German replacement market releases, March 2025 and March 2026. ADAC all-season tyre test 2025, 16 tyres, 205/55 R16. Michelin ten-year CrossClimate review, European all-season volumes. Regulation (EU) 2024/1257 on tyre abrasion; UN abrasion regime; Regulation (EU) 2023/1115 on deforestation-free supply chains. UN Regulation No. 117 paragraph 6.5.1. Pheonix Research, Global All-Season Car Tyres Market, 2026–2033. Related Pheonix reports: Hatchback & Sedan Tyres and SUV & Crossover Tyres.
