Editorial Article
Seven Point Two Three Per Cent Against Three Point One Per Cent: Two Advertising Businesses, Two Denominators
Zepto’s advertising is 7.23% of its operating revenue. Instacart’s is 3.1% of its gross transaction value. One of those numbers is more than twice the other, and neither business is more than twice as good at selling advertising.
They are not the same measurement. Zepto’s is struck against what it books as revenue — after its inventory sits upstream in procurement and distribution. Instacart’s is struck against the full value of the goods it moves for other retailers. Put the two on the same base and a good deal of the gap closes.
This is the most common error made in reading retail media disclosures across quick commerce, and it is worth walking through slowly because the sector is about to supply a lot more of them.
What each denominator actually contains
Zepto reported INR 1,636 crore of advertising receipts in FY26, 7.23% of operating revenue. That revenue line is not a commission line. Zepto flipped from inventory-led to marketplace in January 2025 and pushed its inventory leg upstream into procurement and distribution, but that leg still booked INR 17,588 crore of traded goods in FY26 — roughly 78% of its revenue. The company is substantially a distributor that also runs a platform, and its revenue reflects the goods it moves rather than the cut it takes.
Instacart reported USD 37,224 million of gross transaction value in 2025 across 338.8 million orders at a USD 109.87 average order, and its advertising is 3.1% of that full figure. Instacart runs no stores and owns no inventory; it earns a commission on somebody else’s groceries and sells placements against the same transaction.
| Platform | What the percentage is struck against | Advertising revenue | Stated share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zepto | Operating revenue, including INR 17,588 crore of traded goods — about 78% of the line | INR 1,636 crore FY26 | 7.23% |
| Instacart | Gross transaction value — the full value of goods moved for other retailers | not separately stated here | 3.1% |
Why the base you choose changes the business you are looking at
An advertising business attached to a distributor and an advertising business attached to a marketplace are structurally different companies, and the difference is not cosmetic.
The distributor’s advertising sits on top of a revenue line that already contains the goods. Every rupee of advertising is incremental to a business whose gross revenue is large and whose margin is thin. The marketplace’s advertising sits on top of a commission line. Every dollar of advertising is incremental to a business whose revenue is a fraction of the goods it moves, which makes the same absolute advertising income a far larger share of its own economics.
That is the trap. A marketplace that reports advertising at 3.1% of GTV may be earning more per order than a distributor reporting 7.23% of revenue, and there is no way to tell from the two percentages alone. Anyone building a league table of “retail media intensity” across quick commerce without normalising the base will produce a ranking of business models, not of performance.
The rule worth carrying
Three questions, in order, before any retail media percentage is compared to any other. What is the denominator: revenue, net revenue, commission, or gross transaction value? Does the operator own the inventory inside that denominator? And is advertising disclosed gross or net of the traffic-acquisition cost of getting the advertiser there?
Most disclosures answer the first and leave the second and third to inference. That is not a reason to avoid the numbers — the direction of travel is consistent across every operator that discloses at all, with advertising growing faster than the commerce it sits on. It is a reason to state the base in the same sentence as the figure, every time.
At the sector level the picture is cleaner than any single platform’s ratio. Quick commerce advertising was USD 3.44 billion on USD 203.6 billion of order value in 2025 — a 1.69% take rate across the whole market — reaching 2.46% and USD 14.70 billion by 2033. That number is struck against order value for every operator, which is the only basis on which they can honestly be added up.
Zepto figures are from its updated draft red herring prospectus dated 8 June 2026; Instacart figures are 2025 disclosures. The denominator reconciliation and the market-level take-rate bridge are in the Quick Commerce Retail Media Market report.
Sources
The two denominators compared in this article are both disclosed, which is what makes them comparable as rates and not comparable as businesses:
- Zepto Limited, UDRHP-I filed with SEBI, June 2026 — advertising revenue of INR 1,635.7 crore against operating revenue of INR 22,623.5 crore, the 7.23% figure.
- Instacart (Maplebear Inc.), Form 10-K for fiscal year 2025 — advertising and other revenue against gross transaction value, the 3.1% figure, and total revenue.
The point of the article is that one operator books the goods it sells and the other books a commission on goods it does not, so the two rates are computed on different bases. Pheonix states which denominator is being used whenever a take rate appears.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why can't Zepto's 7.23% be compared with Instacart's 3.1%?
Zepto's 7.23% is struck against operating revenue that includes INR 17,588 crore of traded goods, about 78% of the line, because its inventory leg sits upstream in procurement and distribution. Instacart's 3.1% is struck against USD 37,224 million of gross transaction value — the full value of goods moved for other retailers. Different bases, so the two percentages are not comparable.
Does a higher advertising share of revenue mean a better advertising business?
No. A distributor's advertising sits on top of a revenue line that already contains the goods, so each rupee is incremental to a large, thin-margin turnover. A marketplace's advertising sits on top of a commission line, so the same income is a far larger share of its own economics. A marketplace at 3.1% of GTV may earn more per order than a distributor at 7.23% of revenue.
What should be checked before comparing two retail media disclosures?
What the denominator is — revenue, net revenue, commission or gross transaction value. Whether the operator owns the inventory inside that denominator. And whether advertising is disclosed gross or net of the cost of acquiring the advertiser. Most disclosures answer the first and leave the other two to inference.
How does Pheonix size retail media across the market?
Order value, applied consistently to every operator: USD 3.44 billion of advertising on USD 203.6 billion of order value in 2025, a 1.69% take rate, reaching 2.46% and USD 14.70 billion by 2033. That is the only basis on which platforms with different revenue models can honestly be added together.
