Editorial Article

The Law Prices the Bay-Hour Above 50 Kilowatts and Nowhere Else — and That Is Exactly the Wrong Half of the Estate

Updated November 20, 2026

Regulation (EU) 2023/1804 contains one provision that concedes what this market is actually trading. Article 5(4) allows operators of publicly accessible charging points at 50 kW and above to levy an occupancy fee, priced per minute, explicitly to discourage long occupancy, and displayed before the session begins.

It is the only place in either the European or the British framework where the law admits that a charging bay’s time has a price. It applies above 50 kW. The overstay problem is worst below it.

Europe: a quantity obligation, not a price signal

Article 3 of the same regulation is the more consequential instrument, because it sets a quantity rather than funding a project. Member States must ensure that publicly accessible recharging stations deliver a total power output of at least 1.3 kW for every light-duty battery electric vehicle registered in their territory, and 0.80 kW for every plug-in hybrid, measured at the end of each year from 2024. The requirement is cumulative and national. A Member State that falls short has no discretion: it must add power, and the cheapest place to add it is an existing parking asset, where the civil works, the grid connection and the arriving customer already exist.

There is an escape clause. Where battery electric vehicles reach at least 15 per cent of the fleet and a Member State can demonstrate that the obligation is discouraging private investment, it may seek authorisation to apply lower requirements. As of the sources reviewed for this analysis, no such authorisation had been granted.

Note what a quantity obligation does not do. It counts kilowatts, not bay-hours. A Member State could satisfy Article 3 by installing slow posts in long-stay car parks and degrade the utilisation of the whole network in the process, and would be fully compliant while doing it.

Article 5 and the three commercial provisions

Ad hoc access. Operators must allow recharging without a contract, and at points deployed from 13 April 2024 that must be possible with a widely used payment instrument — card or contactless, or for points below 50 kW a QR-code based internet payment. From 1 January 2027, every public point at 50 kW or above on the TEN-T road network and at safe and secure parking areas, including those deployed before April 2024, must offer card or contactless payment.

Pricing. Prices must be reasonable, easily and clearly comparable, transparent and non-discriminatory, with no differentiation between end users or between mobility service providers, and any differentiation must be proportionate and objectively justified.

Occupancy. At points of 50 kW and above the ad hoc price is based on the kilowatt-hour, and an occupancy fee per minute may be added to discourage long occupancy, with both displayed before the session starts.

That last provision is the whole of the repricing instrument, and it is scoped to the fifth of the estate that already turns over quickly. The bays that sit occupied for four hours behind a fully charged vehicle are almost all below 50 kW, where none of this applies.

The United Kingdom: transparency, and an admission inside it

The Public Charge Point Regulations 2023 came into force on 24 November 2023 and apply across the United Kingdom to charge points accessible to the public, including those providing electricity free of charge.

Requirement Scope Deadline
Pricing transparency in p/kWh, with all fixed fees included All public charge points Immediate (24 November 2023)
Contactless payment New points 8 kW and above; existing points 50 kW and above 24 November 2024
99 per cent reliability, published annually with a report to the Secretary of State Rapid charge point networks 24 November 2024
Free 24/7 staffed telephone helpline, advertised at every point All public charge points 24 November 2024
Open data via OCPI, machine-readable, available to network operators and government All public charge points 24 November 2024
Payment through at least one roaming provider All public charge points 24 November 2025

The pricing rule is the most revealing sentence in either regime. Where charging is sold alongside parking in a single combined price, the portion of that price relating to charging must be clearly displayed separately in p/kWh. Read that as a legislator’s finding of fact: the industry had bundled two products with different cost drivers into one number, and the bundle concealed which one was expensive. The regulation does not require the products to be unbundled. It requires the seam to be visible.

The reliability rule is the second revelation. A 99 per cent availability obligation across a rapid network, measured annually and reported to the Secretary of State, is a genuine constraint with genuine consequences. It does not reach the 56 per cent of the UK estate rated between 3 and 8 kW. Neither does the contactless duty below 8 kW. The regime is rigorous for the fast fifth of the estate and light-touch for the slow majority — and the slow majority is the one that determines how long a bay is held.

America: programme-led, and pointed at the harder site

The National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure programme allocated USD 5 billion under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law to build fast charging along designated corridors. By the end of 2024 roughly USD 30 million had been spent on charging points in operation. In 2025 states drew down about USD 94 million of the USD 4.4 billion available, delivering 497 ports at 99 locations against 18,041 fast ports added nationally — 2.8 per cent of the year’s additions, from a programme holding a large share of the public money.

The design explains the performance. A corridor exists for the minority of journeys that are long, so corridor charging is structurally low-utilisation; the site is chosen for the road it sits beside, not for the traffic that stops. A parking asset has the opposite profile. The customer arrives regardless of state of charge and stays for a reason unconnected to charging, which is the best demand profile in the market. The United States funded the harder site type, and the private market grew roughly 30 per cent without it.

The gap: availability is mandated, throughput is valued, the bay-hour is unpriced

Across both regimes the obligations run to availability, payment, transparency and data. None of them prices duration, except the optional occupancy fee at high power. The result is a market in which the legally mandated product is availability, the commercially valued product is throughput, and the scarce resource — the bay-hour — has no price anywhere in the framework.

An operator in full compliance with both regimes can be destroying value in every busy hour of the day, and nothing in either framework would tell them. The 3.01 per cent utilisation disclosed by Q-Park across 7,310 ports is what that looks like from the inside: a number that reads as an indictment and is in fact a specification.

The equity trap underneath it

The obvious reform is to extend occupancy pricing below 50 kW, and the technical barrier is trivial. The political barrier is severe, because slow charging is where residents without driveways depend on the network. A per-minute fee on an alternating-current post falls hardest on the driver who has nowhere else to charge, and any operator or authority that moves first will be accused of charging people for being poor.

That is the trap, and it is worth stating precisely. The place where the bay-hour is scarcest is the place where pricing it is politically most expensive. The honest counter-argument is that the bay-hour has a cost whether or not anyone prices it, and the driver who cannot find a working post because four cars are fully charged and still plugged in pays that cost too — in a currency that appears on no invoice.

Three things that would move the perimeter

An occupancy mechanism below 50 kW. Either as an extension of the European provision or as a voluntary standard term adopted by the large operators, this is the single change that would give the alternating-current estate a repricing tool. It is also the change most likely to be postponed.

Bay-level metering and disclosure. The United Kingdom already requires the charging component of a bundled parking price to be separated out. Extending that principle to disclose the bay’s occupancy cost would make the trade visible to the driver and, more importantly, to the operator’s own management accounts — which is where the decision to install 22 kW hardware against an 11 kW vehicle currently escapes unchallenged.

Flexibility markets that pay for interruptibility. A four-hour 11 kW session is inherently interruptible in a way that a fifteen-minute 300 kW session is not. If network operators and aggregators pay for that flexibility at a level reflecting its value, the slow estate acquires a second revenue stream and stops depending on energy margin alone. That is the reform that requires no legislation at all.

What the regulation will not do

It will not tell an operator which product they are selling, and it will not price the hour. Both regimes were written for a market in which charging was scarce and availability was the binding constraint, and they are still being applied to an estate that has since become mostly slow, where the binding constraint is time. The regulation has arrived. The repricing has not. The distance between the two is where this market’s returns will be decided over the next eight years.

Method and sources

This article draws on the Pheonix report Global EV Charging at Parking Assets Market 2026–2033, and on the analyses around it: on-street enforcement and digital permitting, parking management and concession operations, curb and kerbside management, occupancy sensing and space guidance, airport pre-booked reservation platforms, parking access and revenue control systems and smartphone credential readers.

Roughly 70 per cent of the underlying weight is secondary, and the primary texts are the spine of it: Regulation (EU) 2023/1804 as consolidated, particularly Articles 3 and 5; the Public Charge Point Regulations 2023 and the accompanying OZEV guidance; federal programme reporting under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law; the Department for Transport and Zapmap public charging device statistics for 1 October 2025; the International Energy Agency’s Global EV Outlook 2025; Q-Park’s Annual CSR Report 2025 and APCOA’s ESG Report 2025 for the operator-side view; and the New York State Department of Public Service capacity-constraints filing of December 2025.

Roughly 30 per cent is Pheonix primary work: 27 semi-structured interviews across six markets, nine conference-floor interviews, one closed roundtable with operators, charge point operators and local authority officers, and 41 survey responses, conducted through 2025 and early 2026. The estimate that the 3–8 kW band carries the great majority of overstay events is ours, drawn from that fieldwork, and is not a published statistic.

The 2.8 per cent share of national fast-port additions, the 46.2 and 29.3 per cent shares of the market increment, and the growth rates cited here were computed from the underlying figures rather than quoted.

References

  • Regulation (EU) 2023/1804 on the deployment of alternative fuels infrastructure, Articles 3 and 5.
  • The Public Charge Point Regulations 2023, SI 2023 No. 1168.
  • Office for Zero Emission Vehicles, guidance accompanying the Public Charge Point Regulations 2023.
  • Department for Transport and Zapmap, Public electric vehicle charging device statistics, 1 October 2025.
  • International Energy Agency, Global EV Outlook 2025.
  • Q-Park N.V., Annual CSR Report 2025.
  • APCOA Parking Holdings GmbH, ESG Report 2025.
  • New York State Department of Public Service, capacity-constraints filing, December 2025.
  • Federal programme reporting under the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure programme.